Complete guide to finding, vetting, and hiring the right general contractor for your construction or renovation project
Choosing the right general contractor is one of the most critical decisions you'll make for your construction or renovation project. A qualified contractor can transform your vision into reality, while the wrong choice can lead to delays, cost overruns, and subpar workmanship. This comprehensive guide will walk you through every step of selecting a reliable, licensed general contractor in Pennsylvania and New Jersey.
Whether you're planning a kitchen remodel in Allentown, a home addition in Bethlehem, or a commercial project in Trenton, the principles of contractor selection remain the same. By following this guide, you'll be equipped to make an informed decision that protects your investment and ensures quality results.
Your general contractor is responsible for coordinating all aspects of your project, from obtaining permits to managing subcontractors, ordering materials, and ensuring quality workmanship. The right contractor will:
Conversely, hiring an unqualified or unlicensed contractor can result in costly mistakes, project delays, code violations, and even legal issues. In Pennsylvania and New Jersey, working with unlicensed contractors can also void insurance claims and create liability problems.
Pennsylvania doesn't require a state-level general contractor license, but many municipalities do. However, contractors must register with the PA Attorney General's Office if they perform home improvement work.
Important: Always ask for the contractor's registration number and verify it matches their business name. Unregistered contractors cannot legally perform home improvement work in Pennsylvania.
New Jersey requires contractors to be licensed by the Division of Consumer Affairs. Contractors must pass exams and meet experience requirements.
Important: Verify the license is active, matches the contractor's business name, and covers the type of work you need. New Jersey has different license categories (home improvement, general contractor, etc.).
Never work with a contractor who cannot provide proof of insurance. Proper insurance protects you from liability if someone is injured on your property or if the contractor's work causes damage.
Minimum $1 million coverage. Protects against property damage and bodily injury. Request a certificate of insurance (COI) and verify it's current.
Required if the contractor has employees. Protects you from liability if a worker is injured on your property. Verify coverage even for small contractors.
Some contractors carry builder's risk insurance, professional liability, or umbrella policies. Ask about coverage specific to your project type.
Red Flag: If a contractor says they're "insured" but cannot provide certificates, or if their insurance has lapsed, do not hire them. Always call the insurance company to verify the policy is active.
Interview at least 3 contractors before making a decision. Prepare a list of questions and take notes during each interview. A professional contractor will welcome your questions and provide detailed answers.
Always get written estimates from at least 3 contractors. Compare not just price, but also materials, timelines, warranties, and payment schedules.
Compare line items: materials, labor, permits, cleanup. The lowest bid may cut corners on materials or skip important steps.
Ensure all contractors are bidding the same quality materials. Ask for specific brand names and model numbers.
Compare project duration and start dates. Unrealistically short timelines may indicate cutting corners.
Avoid contractors who want full payment upfront. Standard is 10-30% deposit, then payments tied to milestones.
Compare warranty terms. Look for at least 1 year on workmanship, plus manufacturer warranties on materials.
Warning: Extremely Low Bids
If one bid is 30%+ lower than others, be very cautious. This often indicates: using inferior materials, cutting corners, lack of insurance, or the contractor will add "change orders" later. Always ask why their price is so much lower.
If you encounter any of these red flags, end the conversation and move on to another contractor. Legitimate contractors will never pressure you, avoid paperwork, or ask for unusual payment terms.
Never start work without a detailed written contract. The contract protects both you and the contractor by clearly defining expectations, costs, and responsibilities.
Tip: Have a lawyer review contracts for large projects ($50,000+). For smaller projects, ensure all key terms are clearly stated. Never sign a contract with blank spaces or vague language.
For projects in the Lehigh Valley (Allentown, Bethlehem, Easton), verify contractors are familiar with local building departments and permit processes. Each city has slightly different requirements.
For projects in Trenton, Ewing, or other NJ municipalities, ensure your contractor is licensed in New Jersey specifically. PA licenses don't transfer to NJ.
Choosing the right general contractor requires time and due diligence, but it's an investment that pays dividends throughout your project. By following this guide, verifying licenses and insurance, checking references, and carefully reviewing contracts, you'll significantly increase your chances of a successful project.
Remember: the cheapest contractor is rarely the best choice. Focus on finding a contractor who is licensed, insured, experienced with your type of project, communicates well, and provides fair pricing. A quality contractor will welcome your questions and provide all requested documentation.
12-step printable guide to vetting and hiring a contractor
Cost guides, checklists, and expert articles for your project
Complete pricing breakdown for home renovations in PA & NJ
Which projects deliver the highest return on investment